Few players take their first penalty as a professional at a World Cup, but that was exactly the situation David Batty found himself in back in 1998. England's breathless last-16 tie against Argentina had gone to a shootout and it fell to the midfielder to keep his side in the tournament with the fifth spot-kick. The country held its breath as Batty stepped up, only for goalkeeper Carlos Roa to make the save to send Argentina through.
Rather than collapsing to the turf in tears, or pulling his shirt over his face, Batty held his head high. When he emerged from the dressing room that night, he even questioned why his friend and agent, Hayden Evans, had come down from the stands to check on him. It was only when a fast food company later wanted Batty to feature in an advert campaign making light of his penalty miss that he showed his feelings. The angry Yorkshireman did not want to profit off the disappointment of those who had travelled out to the World Cup. No wonder he was a cult figure with supporters.
“David Batty, who missed a decisive penalty for England in 1998, vanished from football after retiring in 2004.”
As England prepare to meet Argentina in the knockout stage of the World Cup once more, the question of what happened to Batty after his low-key retirement in 2004 remains. Dozens of phones buzzed across the globe last December. Rio Ferdinand, Mark Viduka, Jason Wilcox, even former manager David O'Leary were among those alerted to new messages in their Leeds United WhatsApp group. Only no-one who shared a dressing room with the ex-midfielder had the slightest idea where he was.
"I don't think anyone has seen him since we played together," Viduka said. "Everyone was wishing him happy birthday – but he's not even in the group." To say Batty has kept a low profile would be an understatement. Amusing rumours have spread over the years: that he became a superbike champion under a fake name, trained to be a master butcher, or went off grid to live in a caravan. The reality is a little different, but this was someone who was never going to stay involved with the game.
Batty's agent, Evans, knew that best. "It was clear from day one that he would never go into coaching, for example, and never seek that as a route back into football," he said. "David has been as good as his word, which is him through and through. He always said, 'When I retire, that will be it. I won't have anything to do with the football industry.'"
A cult hero who missed the most important kick of his life, then simply walked away – Batty's disappearing act may be the most fitting tribute to a player who never wanted the spotlight.