Harry Kane's role in England's World Cup exit: explained

The USA President criticised England's tactics in the 2026 World Cup semi-final. Donald Trump questioned why England captain Harry Kane was used in a defensive role during the 2-1 loss to Argentina. The match, played on 17 July 2026, saw England take the lead through Anthony Gordon before two late Argentina goals, inspired by Lionel Messi, sealed a comeback. Manager Thomas Tuchel's decision to switch to a back five and make defensive substitutions in the closing stages drew widespread criticism from pundits and fans. Trump, who has played golf with Kane in Florida, said: "I think they perhaps made a mistake when they made him a defensive player. They took the lead and took their best player and put him on defence." Tuchel brushed off Trump's comments in a news conference. Kane had scored six goals in the tournament up to that point. The debate centres on whether England's most prolific striker should be used to protect a lead or left to attack. The third-place play-off against France, often called the 'bronze final' by FIFA, will be England's chance to bounce back. Argentina will face Spain in the final on Sunday. This episode highlights the eternal tension in football between defence and attack – and the pressure on managers to get it right.